Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Moltmannia: Wrestling with a Ghost

After my last post, I'm wondering if this poem from awhile back is actually an argument against the impassibility of God. Am I wrestling with God, or with the ideas about God that I've inherited?

Or maybe I'm just beginning to understand what it is to feel loss. Maybe the simple sadness I feel is precisely what God feels about the loss of his son, and about all of the other losses that people throughout the world and throughout time feel. Maybe this sense of utter, profound loss is the beginning point of hope. Maybe there is a kind of accumulation of all of this sadness and loss that God means to redeem as God invites us to join in the remaking of heaven and earth.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Moltmannia: The Weakness of Omnipotence


As a 'blasphemer', Jesus was rejected by the guardians of his people's law. As a 'rebel' he was crucified by the Romans. But finally, and most profoundly, he died as one rejected by his God and his Father. In the theological context of his life this is the most important dimension.
...in his conflict with the law it was possible to speak of a 'misunderstanding' on the part of the Jews. In the political conflict of his crucifixion as a rebel it is customary to speak of a 'misunderstanding' on the part of the Romans. But is it possible to speak of a 'misunderstanding' in the theological context of his abandonment by God? If so, either Jesus must have misunderstood God in his preaching, or God must have misunderstood Jesus at the end of his life... (CG, 152)

In his masterful work The Crucified God, JürgenMoltmann means to steadily and unapologetically bring us to face the true horror of the cross of Jesus. Which is not only that Jesus suffered and died a torturous, miserable death, but what was even worse: he was abandoned there by God. This is something we instinctively flinch at, and turn away from because it is so horrible, and hard to imagine, and so contrary to the feel-good lines we often hear about God and Jesus. Yet in this abandonment, there is hope. For in it, we can know that both God and Jesus understand what it is to be forsaken and alone.

This contrasts sharply with the training I received at a conservative seminary in my youth. It wasn't a Reformed school, but we certainly heard from a lot of reformed professors. One of the main points they emphasized was the impassibility of God, which portrays God as unswayed by feeling and emotion. Sure, we were told that God feels love, and compassion, and that God cares about people. But above and beyond that, we were told that God was not overly affected by such human emotions, and that God surely didn't sway based on such shifty things. No, God was literally impassible-- unable to suffer and to to be affected by these feelings and by the actions of humans. This is what made God both God and good.

Which view Moltmann deals with directly:
...a God who is only omnipotent is in himself an incomplete being, for he cannot experience helplessness and powerlessness. Omnipotence can indeed be longed for and worshipped by helpless men, but omnipotence is never loved; it is only feared. What sort of being, then, would be a God who was only 'almighty'? He would be a being without experience, a being without destiny and a being loved by no one. A man who experiences helplessness, a man who suffers because he loves, a man who can die, is therefore a richer being than an omnipotent God who cannot suffer, cannot love and cannot die. (CG, 223)
This idea of omnipotence as 'incompleteness' certainly resonates with me, and reminds me of Jack Caputo. His 'Weakness of God' seems to some to be an assault on God, or at least of the essence/nature of God. But to those who have suffered (or, I should say, to those who are aware of and honest about their suffering), thinking of God as 'weak' or as more/less than omnipotent is a great comfort, and gives great hope. Where Caputo commends the weakness of God, Moltmann champions the poverty of God as he describes a God who has need and want and loss and absence. The traditional Reformation view of God as 'unmoved' (dependent as it is on Greek philosophy) depicts a God who 'cannot love, and cannot suffer' (CG, 253)
A God who is conceived of in his omnipotence, perfection, and infinity at man's expense cannot be the God who is love in the cross of Jesus, who makes a human encounter in order to restore their lost humanity to unhappy and proud divinities, who 'became poor to make many rich'. (CG, 250)

I'm With the Band

Daley is posed in front of his classic amp (srsly, the case was signed by Hendrix's guitar tech when he modded it in '72. It's as round and mellow as a hundred circles drinking a thousand beers). He has haystack hair and a Fender slung down by his thigh. But for all his cool, he's all business: a stone-cold professional with 10 gigs left on this tour. Playing behind a bangled chick who was super-excited to put me on the guest list because she imagines I'm some kind of industry connection, and she'd like to show me how Hollywood she is. And did she mention that she's about to sign a major-label deal?

He works hard at being effortless, and plays like Keith Richards' younger and purer soul, bending his lanky frame into a question mark to release each note into the world. Then he unplugs, wraps his cables, and heads for a cup of ice water. Ten shows to go.

Friday, August 21, 2009

Moltmannia: Getting out of the Ghetto


Before he even begins his book The Crucified God (which is meant as a companion and balance to his Theology of Hope), Moltmann throws down the gauntlet. He states with little equivocation that Jesus' cry from the cross, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" is the center of Christianity. Indeed, he says that all of philosophy and history is an attempt to answer this question.

Though the book was originally published in German in 1972, we once again find ourselves listening to what feels like a very insightful commentary on the current scene. These days, my neo-monastic friends criticize my emergence friends as being 'too relevant', saying that Christianity must be counter-cultural if it is to have any worth. And my emergence friends feel a sense of exasperation, since we're not trying to be 'relevant' per se, but to image a Christianity that makes sense to us and to our friends. Sure, we could be more radical, but what we hear and repeat from Jesus is already more than anyone can live into... are we trying to be too hipster, too cool, too trendy? Should we all cash in (what's left of) our 401Ks and live in a van down by the river?

The prescient Moltmann speaks directly to this dilemma in his introduction. We need, he says, both relevance and identity. We need both relevance and irrelevance. For if the church is like everyone else, then it is a meaningless hanger-on. But the church also needs to be radically open to others-- 'self-emptying' for the sake of others, and offering radical hospitality to those who would inquire. We often debate about the possibility of Christianity becoming either mainstream or ghettoized, but Moltmann suggests that if Christians see themselves as a 'remnant', then they will tend to withdraw into a ghetto (and to reinforce their rightness through and by their continued alienation).

Moltmann points to the cross as a solution and litmus test for this conundrum. Focus on the cross, he says, and individuals and groups will be forced to live in the tension of relevance/irrelevance. Focus on the cross, and individuals and groups will find their identity in the cross. Even more importantly, the cross keeps us from having a theology of theology (per Aquinas). In Moltmann's view, theology must never be pure theory. And a robust theology of the cross (whether Luther's or subsequent iterations, like this one of Moltmann) ensures that theology and Christianity avoid the irrelevance of indulging in purity.

Ambivalence


I've been aware lately that I don't write about and celebrate our newest child as much as her brother and sister. Surely this is common for younger siblings, as they are unfortunately lost in the shuffle of the family, and as their accomplishments are overshadowed by their older siblings. Plus we parents can quickly get a case of 'been there, done that' and under-emphasize the developmental milestones of our younger kids.

But in spite of my ambivalence, our little baby is indeed growing up. She finally decided to take a bottle, which still feels like a dream every time she lunges her open mouth toward that nipple-- after so many deafening attempts to cajole her into taking that which she demanded (but refused), I'm nearly moved to tears each time she enjoys a meal in my arms. And after several weeks of wedging her into her bassinet, we finally broke down and got the crib out of storage to set it up this week. I had expected her to be lost in its expanse, but she fills it out nicely: the little girl is growing up.

Which, upon further reflection, might be why I'm subconsciously shining on her many milestones and developments. Because even as I'm thrilled to see her thriving and interacting with the world, there is a tiny part of me that doesn't want her to grow up. Even as she-- and we!-- find new happiness in her regular feedings, I know this is yet another step toward her eventual independence. She is in all likelihood our final child, and I want her to stay tiny so I can nibble on her cheeks and rub her stubby hair and feel the dimples on her plump elbows, forever. She needs to grow up, but I want to keep her small. She's blossoming before my eyes, but I want to keep her as my baby.

But you go on and grow up, Anna Lucia. It's good for both of us.

Thursday, August 20, 2009

Utter Summer



great photos by Ken.

What does one do when it's 99 degrees and at least that much humidity? Well, go to the county fair, of course. At the kind invitation of Ella's friend Kieran and Annie Lu's friend Tristan, we drove out in the afternoon sun to dive into the all-American experience of this great tradition. Which is to say, the smell of sweat, the taste of fat, and the mellow pleasure of second-hand smoke. Add in a few rides that would make OSHA stand on its head, and you're having a great time.

We grownups indulged in the true pleasure of such places-- watching the faces of kids who are utterly trilled by moving in slow circles. And then dragged those same kids along to see a demolition derby (the first two heats of small cars were disappointing, but the two V-8 heats had thrills to spare). I'd never before seen a radiator actually pop, nor witnessed the staggering bravery of the guy who climbed through his windshield to try to blow out his engine fire. Oh, sure, our tender daughter was concerned about the cars 'playing too rough', and was right about it being 'too noisy' (though she might have been addressing the loud outbursts of her father), but she will get over it. I hope.

All of which was capped off by family funnel cakes with a side order of heady talk about Jurgen Moltmann. Then for the drive home with slumbering kids, an argument in my stomach between the smoked turkey leg and the funnel cake, and daydreams about running the family station wagon in next year's derby. I'll bust out the windows myself, and fill the driver's door with concrete, and with all-wheel-drive, I'll bet I could take the trophy and the cash in the V-6 heat...

Monday, August 17, 2009

Moltmannia: Intoxicated by the Jürgenmeister



As I got to the end of Moltmann's Theology of Hope, I found myself uplifted by all manner of insights. All of which enlivened my thinking as they bubbled up with that always amusing experience of simultaneously saying, "I never thought of that!", and "That meshes exactly with what I have always known!"
  • The cross and the resurrection might not be different modi for Jesus, but rather a dialectic that will only resolve in the synthesis that is the eschaton. Or perhaps it is the self-Kingdoming of Jesus-- the Crucified has arisen without any interference by God, because the Crucified is God. Or, to borrow some Matrix terminology, 'The One is the One because he is the One".
  • So the eschaton is about an 'imminent arrival'. Yet it is also a current presence. Therefore, the parousia of Christ is not separated from the reality of Christ today. The present is a part of the future, and vice versa.
  • The Bible, then, has no magical quality. Rather it looks to the future fulfillment of God's promise-- it looks beyond itself as it announces the future of the truth. "It communicates this truth in such a way that we can have it only by confidently waiting for it and wholeheartedly seeking it." (ToH, 320)
  • So this eschatological horizon is a mission for the future of the world (Moltmann was using current buzzwords like 'mission' and 'a church for the world' long before many hotshot church leaders emerged from their mothers' wombs). The horizon of expectation is where we apply our "believing obedience, our discipleship, and our love" (ToH, 334).
All of which reminds me that doing theology and doing church is a profoundly creative work. Though too many of us are preoccupied with the past and overly fixated on the present, Moltmann shows us the startling truth that God has been-- all along, and since time out of mind-- looking past us to the future that God is bringing to be. Which is not to say that God is unconcerned about us and our contributions toward that preferred future-- no, indeed, for God is asking us to join in that work of making the world the way it ought to be. And that world is right there on the horizon. We just need to keep moving toward it.

The New World


Shortly after buying the small house that we will inhabit after we do some renovations, I brought a sample of the unidentified hardwood flooring to the local high-end lumberyard. I needed a few hundred square feet to correct some misjudgments by the previous renovator. "What's this?" I asked nervously as I stepped up to the lumber sales counter. I figured that it was either maple or cherry, but have learned that it's best to just start from The Dumb and learn everything you can.

"Oh, it's cherry," he said, "American cherry". This caused my heart to leap and fall at the same time, since I knew that domestic cherry is gorgeous, but expensive to replace. And my lumber friend gave it to me straight: "We can't even make this for you, and I doubt anyone else has it. You'd better start looking for some at salvage yards." The resignation of the carpenter customers waiting in line confirmed it: my goose was cooked.

Still, he sent me on a long-shot search at a flooring specialty store up the road. Which I walked into brandishing two little girls (which isn't exactly kosher at such places) and the same dumb question as I laid the flooring samples on the counter. Which got me the same answer, and a short conference among two employees as to whether they could get any of this stuff. They could, it turned out, but only for a premium. They actually apologized as they quoted me the price-- almost $5 per square foot.

I checked into the option of finding some used flooring that had been salvaged from old buildings. There are actually quite a few local companies that warehouse old relics like this, but none of them had any American cherry. Still, I swallowed hard as I asked what it would cost if/when they did get any, and was astonished to hear prices all the way up to $15/sq.ft..

Which would have been the end of the line back when I started to work in the remodeling trade. But now, I fire up Google and see what's out there. And what is out there is American cherry for $3/sq. ft. Plus stair nosing and risers and cove and even shoe, if I want it. But the true 21st-century twist came in the geography. The flooring supply house, you see, is in Florida. But they don't warehouse the lumber there-- it comes straight from the mill in Tennessee. And when I was closing the deal with the salesman on the phone today, he mentioned that he lives in Grand Rapids, Michigan. And that he's interested in emergence churches.

Small world, I guess. Or big. Or something.

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Moltmannia: Resurrection of Resurrection


I snuck a peek at Moltmann's autobiography yesterday, and learned that he has overseen 200 doctoral students. That is 200 people who have done extensive, original research to bring to light the intricacies of his work. That's a lot, but I'm quickly realizing that it isn't nearly enough.

On the topic of 'resurrection' alone, the man unfurls a beautiful landscape. Resurrection, he says, brings into clear view at least two horizons. First, the glory of God's lordship is understood to be moving toward human beings. At the same time, resurrection signals the current breaking in of God's future. We look back at one horizon, even as we see another horizon approaching. And we realize once again that movement is an implicit and important part of Moltmann's conception of theology. We are nomads, and we make sense of things by moving.

Which is a helpful corrective, since so many other theologians seem intent only on looking back. What's worse is that they tend to focus only on certain eras of thought. In particular, Moltmann suggests, we fixate on the Hellenistic approach to God, taking on all of the assumptions from Greek metaphysics: perfection, goodness, purity, immutability, impassibility, and unity. Even worse than that is the fact that we tend to look upon these matters through the lens of the modern worldview which has a particular perspective of history, and humans in history, and which tends to suggest that history is fulfilled (finally and completely) in Jesus. But these perspectives are far removed from the connection which the Christian story ought to have with Yahweh-- who was the peculiar God of the Jews-- and to Jesus, who was himself a Jew. They leave us impoverished, because they leave us standing beside the path on which we ought to be traveling. We're taking notes and reminiscing when we ought to be lacing up our shoes for a journey.

To make his point, Jurgen points to a bit of Greek wordplay. epangelia is a word that connotes 'promises', 'vows', and 'pledges'. euangelia is very similar, and is often translated 'gospel' or 'announcement'. Moltmann makes the point that these concepts are wonderfully intertangled: "the gospel is promise and as a promise it is an earnest of the promised future" (ToH, 148). The gospel draws us back, even as it propels us forward.

This same tension between the past and the future, Moltmann wisely points out, was a big part of primitive Christianity. Judaic Christianity thought it was forward-focused, what with its determined apocalyptic outlook and fervent expectation of a political Messiah. But it was the unexpected emergence of Gentile Christianity that offered a truly fresh understanding of gospel. This gospel/announcement is of good news for the godless-- of the calling of Gentiles to the God of hope. And that is the truly fresh and future and ongoing work of God in the world, and it is an initiative that has included me and so many others into the story of God. Yet like so many seond- or third-generation immigrants to America, those of us welcomed into the family have a short memory about such hospitality: we forget what is important about the past, even as we proclaim ourselves guardians of the past.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Moltmannia: On the Road Again

Picking up with the money quote from yesterday,
The promises of God disclose the horizons of history-- whereby 'horizon', as it is aptly put by H.G. Gadamer, is not to be understood as 'a rigid boundary', but as 'a thing towards which we are moving, and which moves along with us'. Israel lived within these moving horizons of promise and experienced reality within the fields of tension they involve. Even when the period of nomadic wanderings ended in Palestine, this mode of experiencing, remembering and expecting reality as history still remains nd characterized this people's wholly peculiar relation to time. (ToH, 106)
Most of us live in a post-industrial society. Before that, it was (obviously) industrial. And before that, it was agrarian (for me, this fits neatly into three generations: my grandfather was a farmer, my father still works in manufacturing, and I don't produce much of anything). So it is only natural that we overlay this perspective on our understanding of the Bible. But Moltmann points out that Israel is a nomadic people. So their nomadic religion is a religion of promise. For them, there is no seedtime, and no harvest. There is, however, movement. So their God is inspiring, immigrating, doing, and protecting. Their God is not bound to territory, but rather journeys with them. In their conception God is on the move.

Then, they settled, taking the wilderness God into the cities which they overthrew and occupied. And they themselves became the establishment, the settled, the sedentary. Once they began this shift to agrarian culture, we see the rise of the prophet, who rails against the increasingly settled people and the raises the threat that they might be taken captive by Assyria, Babylon, and Persia, but even more that they would become powers akin to Assyria, Babylon, and Persia. They might be taken captive, but what is even more troubling is that they might collapse under the weight of their own settled inertia.

Which brilliant observation touches on some of the great thinking being done by the Psalters, and in the forthcoming work of Joe Myers. Both of whom are pointing out that we are a post-agrarian culture, and one which is less tied to land and property and place (and factories, jobs, and local communities) than in recent memory. Myers, in particular, cites social media (blogs, Facebook, Twitter, and the like) as examples of this, and coins the term 'technomads' to describe the current scene. Indeed, it is a unique experience to check FB messages in the morning and see activity from around the world streaming into my little life while I've slept. My ties to what is local loosen, even as my connections to people and communities in far-flung places like London, Paris, Sudan, Syria, Australia, Jordan, and Minnesota are strengthened. It is a new day, indeed. Or maybe an old one.

Which make Moltmann's 45-year old words (about an ancient people) all the more weighty:
If the promises of God create an interval of tension between their being issued and their coming to pass, and thereby institue freedom for obedience, then importance attaches to the question of directions for the filling out of this interval and of the existence thus constitued in it. This is understandable, since a promise does not announce an inescapable fate, but sets men on a road that leads to another land and another reality. (ToH, 120)
So for nomads, a promise must combine with obedience, and obedience with a change of place and of existence. Nomads understand that they must get up and go to that place toward which the promise points. So we need both obedience and hope to move toward the horizon that opens before the present. The commandments are future, just like the promises. And whether to a literal or virtual destination, we'd best get a move on.

Sunday, August 09, 2009

Moltmannia: Surfing with Jürgen



As Theology of Hope continues to gain momentum, Moltmann develops the metaphor of 'horizon' in broader and deeper ways. I can't wait to see where Dr. Moltmann and Tony take us with these ideas in Chicago next month.
The promises of God disclose the horizons of history-- whereby 'horizon', as it is aptly put by H.G. Gadamer, is not to be understood as 'a rigid boundary', but as 'a thing towards which we are moving, and which moves along with us'. (ToH, 106)
We move with history, and history moves with us-- the horizons of past and future are real, but like literal horizons, they are ephemeral. One can move toward or away from a horizon, but one will never arrive at a horizon. 'History', then, is seen as a continuum where Israel is able to remember the faithfulness of God initiated (in the past) and to anticipate the faithfulness finally completed (in the future). As such, we should not speak of the facts of history, because to do so would imply an absoluteness, immutability, and finality that is not borne out by a fair understanding of history. Even more to the point, such a static view does not adequately speak to the import of promise, hope, and anticipation that must be part and parcel of a life after God. History is fluid.

All of which (like a lot of things) got me thinking about surfing...

Did a wave happen? Yes, of course. But there is no evidence of it. Once it hits the beach, it is as if it never existed. Yet what is most important about that wave is the experience of it. Such experience is fleeting, ephemeral, and momentary, but it is real.

A fact? I suppose.
Really real? Yes, for it can be measured and recorded.
Provable? I guess.

But experience trumps all of that. A scientist might offer a treatise on the hydraulic features of a wave. A documentarian might capture beautiful images of the wave. And a poet might express the feeling of it. But none of that is as important or interesting as the sensation of being moved by it, or the power expressed in being held down by it, or the joy it gives a child to run into it.

Thursday, August 06, 2009

Moltmannia: Resurrection on the Horizon



The momentum is building for the Moltmann conversation, and the book stack is growing, too. So I'm forging ahead through his first major work, and enjoying it quite a bit. Can't wait to see my friends and to sit at the feet of this august scholar who has shaped so much of theology over the past 50 years.

Through all of his work that I've read so far, the metaphor of 'horizon' is one that is constantly at play. Which is to say that Moltmann sees time as elastic, and relatively unimportant. What matters to him is the future, and the way we're vectoring toward it. So especially for one of the central events in Christian theology, if not human history: the resurrection of Jesus. For Moltmann, this resurrection is not primarily an event in the past as much as a prolepsis for all of history and humanity. The church's yearning for the (yet) future coming of Jesus stands as a reminder that Jesus' resurrection is not just the first resurrection of the dead (of many) but the source of the risen life for all believers.

"They wait for their future by waiting for his future" (Theology of Hope, 83)

So the Risen Christ is not static but marching toward his goal (Barth), and his work is not yet completed, and not yet concluded (Barth again). So, too, for his followers as they follow after him in life and death and resurrection.

I suppose there is some comfort in seeing Jesus as past, staid, static, and finished. In a world of uncertainty and filled with myriad unknown futures, we long for answers, foundations, and moorings. But I'd rather look forward. I'd rather follow a Christ who is still waiting, striving, straining. Who will one day find his fulfillment and rest, who will take his place on the throne, yes, but who is now working alongside those who would join him in the renewal of all things.

Monday, August 03, 2009

Before and After

From my new obsession/provocation/inspiration:


Saturday, August 01, 2009

Another Year, a New Chapter

When she married me 16 years ago, I was a rather uncouth specimen. I had the weathered and creased red neck of a roofer, as well as the coarse and permanently dirty hands to match. When I leaned over to 'Kiss the bride,' I also delivered a dose of the perspiration that had accumulated on my face in that hot church building in Waukegan, IL. And though a honeymoon in southern Wisconsin is perhaps not the stuff of dreams, she made the best of it, and still remembers it with fondness. Though I obviously married out of my league, she doesn't seem to notice.

In the years since, I've become a bit more groomed, refined, and sedate. The wardrobe has been improved a bit, and I'm less likely to cause embarrassment in public (or at least to sweat on anyone). But when we went out for a celebratory lunch yesterday, I needed to remember to keep my hands under the table, since they are starting to look like they did when we first got married. Sixteen years after the fact, we've taken the big step of buying a house. So I've drug the tools out of their dusty repose and dug into a place of our own. What's even better than busying myself with the work is watching her bring a whole new set of skills to bear-- turns out she has some untapped abilities in design and re-imagining interior spaces. The teamwork that we've so enjoyed over the years has sprouted into a new direction, with her imagining what is possible and me trying to make it so. Love blooms anew.